Lindsay Lohan and Lacey Chabert reunited for Andy Cohen

Photo: Bravo/Charles Sykes/Bravo

Throughout their careers, Lindsay Lohan and Lacey Chabert, despite taking divergent paths, have managed to get back together. The Wild girls co-stars are both starring in Netflix Christmas rom-coms this year, so of course the streamer and Andy Cohen are milking this moment for all it’s worth. Chabert’s film features a sly, self-referential scene in which her character watches a clip of Lohan Falling for ChristmasLohan’s 2022 Netflix holiday rom-com, and the two made a cute joint appearance on See what’s happening live! on Wednesday.

Other than the revelation on which they appeared Late Night with David Letterman together in a 1992 Halloween episode, neither offered much in the way of the gossipy fodder usually expected on WWHL. They sweetly made up for it by reviewing some of their old red carpet looks in a game called “So Fetch or That’s Retch” and reminiscing together about their early careers. Basically, they finally made “retrieval” happen! Chabert talked about the five reasons she loves Christmas and what it was like working with Susan Lucci as a child; Lohan talked about real and potential reboots, her favorite pasta recipes and the news that the only project she’s ever had to audition for was The parent trap. None of them mentioned Wild girls the Black Friday theme commercial they did last year, but the true highlight of the episode was their performance of a scene from Wild girlswith Cohen donning Kim Zolciak’s wig to join them as Regina George:

Maybe I’m craving a hit of sentimental nostalgia, but I can’t get over the fact that these two were only brought together by a holiday (Halloween) so early Letterman appearance and that they have been reunited by another (Christmas) with their respective wholesome Netflix rom-coms. These also happen to be the two most prominent and eventful holidays depicted in Wild girls. Just saying!

Photo: ©Paramount/Courtesy Everett Collection